Court of Appeal sends Saraki back to tribunal

Date: 2017-12-13

The Court of Appeal in Abuja yesterday ordered Senate President Bukola Saraki to return to the Code of Conduct Tribunal (CCT) and face three-count charge on alleged false asset declaration.

The three-member panel led by Justice Tinuade Akomolafe-Wilson unanimously ruled that Saraki should return to the CCT to face trial on three counts out of the 18 initially slammed on him. The court dismissed the remaining 15 counts and ordered the remittance of the three charges back to CCT for the continuation of the trial. The Court of Appeal ruled that the federal government failed to call the vital witness to prove its allegations against Saraki, which included that he drew salary four years after leaving office as a governor.

The panel, however, agreed with the EFCC that "there was ample evidence" that discrepancies exist in the claims about the acquisition of the Ikoyi properties on the asset declaration forms, which requires the defendant to make further explanation as public servants are not permitted to engage in any form of business venture apart from agriculture.

"In conclusion, we find no merit in 15 out of 18 count charges brought against the defendant by the complainant and we hereby uphold the decision of the tribunal delivered in June this year on the finding," she said.

"It is my belief that credible evidence was led by the prosecution in respect of the three counts, it is hereby ordered that counts four, five and six be remitted to the tribunal for retrial to enable the defendant offer explanations where necessary," she said.

The senate president and the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) said they would appeal to the Supreme Court.

The three-count charges

In count four charge, Saraki was accused of making false assets declaration at the end of his tenure as Executive Governor of Kwara State in 2011 and on assumption of office as a senator in 2011 in respect of a property at 17A McDonald, Ikoyi Lagos.

The prosecution said Saraki falsely declared to have acquired the property at 17A McDonald, Ikoyi, Lagos on September 6, 2006, from the proceeds of the sale of rice and sugar.

In count five, the prosecution accused Saraki of making false asset declaration at the end of his tenure as Executive Governor of Kwara State in 2011 and on the assumption of office as a senator in 2011 when he declared that he acquired No. 17B McDonald, Ikoyi Lagos on September 6, 2006, from proceeds of the sale of rice and sugar.

In count six, the prosecution also accused Saraki of making a false declaration in his Assets Declaration Form at the end of tenure as Governor of Kwara in 2007 and on the assumption of office as Executive Governor in 2007 by failing to declare his outstanding loan liabilities of N315 million out of the loan of N380 million obtained from Guaranty Trust Bank Plc.

The penalties

The offences are punishable under Paragraphs 11 (2), (3) and (13) of Part 1, 5th Schedule of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999; and Section 23 (2) of the Code of Conduct Tribunal Act with the vacation of elective or nominated office, disqualification from holding public office (whether elective or not) for a period not exceeding 10 years, and seizure of and forfeiture to the state of any property acquired in abuse or corruption.

Sub-section (3) states that "the punishments mentioned in subsection (2) of this section shall be without prejudice to the penalties that may be imposed by any law where the breach of conduct is also a criminal offence under the Criminal Code or any other enactment or law."

The Justice Danladi Umar-led panel of the CCT had in June upheld a no case submission made by Saraki's lawyers, Kanu Agabi, Paul Erokoro, Paul Usoro, and Mahmud Magaji, all Senior Advocates of Nigeria, who contended that the prosecution failed to establish a prima-facie case against him.

Meanwhile, both Saraki's legal team and the EFCC team have hinted that they will both cross-appeal the decision of the Court of Appeal at the Supreme Court.

Paul Erokoro (SAN) said the legal team "is definitely going to appeal the judgment."

The EFCC team led by Rotimi Jacobs (SAN) said they will question many aspects of the judgment, including the court's pronouncement that "burden of proof rests squarely with the prosecution."

Source

 


Cloud Tag: What's trending

Click on a word/phrase to read more about it.

Noah Yusuf     High Court     Lanre Aremu     NURTW     Fatai Adeniyi Garba     Oluwarotimi Boluwatife Adenike     Abdulrahman Abdulrasak     ASUU     Onilorin     Ubandawaki     Amuda Bembe     KSIRS     Arandun     Balikis Jawondo     Lithium     Wahab Femi Agbaje     Ibraheem Abdullateef     Garba Idris Ajia     Sabitiyu Grillo     Fatima Abolore Jimoh     Sai Kayi     Igosun     Sam Onile     Mohammed Kamaludeen     Belgore     Yahaya Muhammad     Ilorin Water Reticulation     PharmAccess Foundation     NITDA     AbdulRasaq Abdulmajeed Alaro     Ibrahim Abdulkadir Abikan     Kamoru Kadiri     Umar Ayinla Saro     Jare Olatundun     Seun Bolaji     Christopher Odetunde     SUBEB     Local Government Pension Board     Isiaka Abdulrazak     JSSCE     AGILE Programme     Towoju     Isaac Aderemi Kolawole     Lola Ashiru     Ibrahim Gambari     Matthew Babaoye     Clara Nwachukwu     Tope Daramola     Omotoso     Bayo Lawal     Hydroelectric Power Producing Areas Development Commission     Kisira     Siraj Oyewale     Abdulkadir Akanbi-Oke     Halimat Yusuf     Forgo Battery Company Limited     Ariyo     Aminat Omodara     Post-utme     Ebola     NULGE     Alikinla     Hassan Taiye Salam     Garba Ayodele Wahab     V.O. Abioye     Bola Iyabo Ibiyeye Adisa     Yusuf Ali     UNIFEMGA     Playing Host     Abdulkadri Ahmad Alaiye     Ahmed Mohammed Rifun     Ganiyu Abolarin     Maryam Ado Bayero     Isiaq Khadeejah     Ajeigbe     Ilorin Central Mosque     Isiaka Saka Opobiyi    

Cloud Tag: What's trending

Click on a word/phrase to read more about it.

Markaz Arabic And Islamic Training Institute, Agege     Cornelius Adebayo     Rice Farmers Association Of Nigeria     Roheemat Hammed     Oloye     Waziri Yakubu Gobir     Okanlawon Musa     Omoniyi M. Ayinla     Sarah Jubril     Bureau Of Lands     Kwara State Pension Board     John Olobayo     Musbau A. Akanji     Ibrahim Gambari     Abdullahi Dasilva Yussuf     General Hospital     Saad Belgore     Chief Imam Of Lafiagi     Abdul Jimoh Mohammed     Muhammadu Gobir     Elekoyangan     Saka Saadu     Olateju Lukman     Yusuf Zulu-Gambari     Javed Khan     International Aviation College     Abdulrauf Yusuf     Mohammed Saidu     AbdulQowiy Olododo     Onilorin Of Ilorin     Zaratu Umar     Post Utme     Fatai Olodo     IEDPU     Ilorin Talaka Parapo     College Of Arabic And Islamic Legal Studies     Oba Abdulrahim     Kabir Shagaya     Muhammed Taofeeq Abdulrazaq     AbdulGafar Tosho     Centre For Peace And Strategic Studies     Baba Isale     Bamikole Omishore     Muazam Nayaya     Saka Balikis Kehinde     Alaiye     Offa Poly     Special Agro-industrial Processing Zone     Oke-Ode     Maimunat Oloriegbe     Amos Justus Sayo     Chief Imam Of Omu-Aran     Temi Kolawole     Ramadhan     Eleyele     Abdulmumin Yinka Ajia     Abdulmalik Bashir Mopelola Risikatullahi     Haruna Tambiri Mohammed     International Vocational Centre     Adeola Abraham     Tuesday Assayomo     Code Of Conduct Bureau     Prince Bola Ajibola     Aisha Abodunrin Ibrahim     Muhammadu Buhari     Oba Abdulkadir La\'aro     Ibrahim Bio     Saadu Gbogbo Iwe     Elelu     Rafiu Ajakaye     Abdulsalam A. Yusuf     JSSCE     Wahab Olasupo Egbewole     Unilorin     Ilofa     Okin Group     PAACO-PCL Consortium