Senate committees: Court rejects moves to stop Saraki

Date: 2015-07-29

A Federal High Court in Abuja has rejected a prayer by five senators opposed to the emergence of Bukola Saraki as the Senate President to stop the upper legislative chamber from constituting its standing and ad hoc committees.

The five plaintiffs in the suit marked FHC/ABJ/CS/651/2015 - Senators Abu Ibrahim, Kabir Marafa, Ajayi Boroffice, Olugbenga Ashafa and Suleiman Hunkuni - made the request in an ex parte application which was moved by their lawyer Chief Mamman Osuman (SAN), on Tuesday.

They had anchored their ex parte application on the use of alleged illegitimate and unconstitutional Senate Standing Orders 2015 to conduct the election of the current leadership of the Senate on June 9.

The plaintiffs alleged that the Senate Standing Orders 2015 was "contrived" from the amendment of the 2011 version of the Orders without following its (the 2011 edition's) relevant provisions and those of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria.

They argued that the said amendment was in breach of the "prescriptive procedures" stipulated by the extant provisions of section 60 of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 (as amended) and Rule 110(1), (2), (3), (4) and (5) of the Senate Standing Orders 2011 (as amended).

In their ex parte application supported by an affidavit of urgency, the plaintiffs had on Tuesday urged the court to stop the constitution of the Senate committees pending the hearing and determination of their separate application for interim injunction.

But Justice Gabriel Kolawole in his ruling dismissed the ex parte application, holding that the urgency attached to it was self-induced.

This, the judge held, was because the plaintiffs had been aware of the alleged use of the illegitimate standing orders since June 9, 2015 but only chose to file the ex parte application dated on July 27, which was barely 24 hours to resumption of the Senate from its about one month recess.

The judge also held that the court would hardly intervene in a matter relating to the application or misapplication of the internal rules of the Senate or the legislature when such action did not amount to "subtantial infraction" of the provisions of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria.

He held that in matters relating to disputes over the "the decision reached by a majority of the members of the Senate", aggrieved members of the arm of government could only seek a redress by mobilising their colleagues to reverse such decision.

He held that in various appellate courts' decisions, courts had been warned "to be wary" in intervening in such internal legislative activities, let alone granting an order to restrain the activities of that arm of government at the stage of an ex parte hearing.

"In the light of the above analysis, I will be unable to grant the ex parte application dated July 24 and only filed on July 27, 2015 by only five out of the 109 senators constitutionally elected to the upper legislative chamber," Justice Kolawole ruled.

He therefore ordered the plaintiffs to serve the motion on notice seeking the same prayer contained in their ex parte application on the defendants.

The judge adjourned hearing of the motion on notice till August 5, adding that after the hearing and upon service of the defendants with the processes of the main suit, he would return the case file to the Chief Judge.

Source

 

Cloud Tag: What's trending

Click on a word/phrase to read more about it.

Iyabo Dupe Adekeye     Vishvas KOZ Tractors     Saliu Alamoyo     Bello Oyedepo     Tsado Manman     Sebastine Obasi     Tope Daramola     Abraysports FC     Omoniyi Ayinla     Elerin Of Erin-Ile     Tunde Mukaila Mustapha     Yusuf Amuda Aluko     Mohammed Danjuma     Muhammed Aliyu     VADA     NIRSAL     Kwara State Governor     Bilikisu Oniyangi     Yahaya A Paniyaro     Aisha Gobir     Okeose Christian Cementary     Oke-Ogun     Eleja     Tunde Yusuf     Sa\'ad Alanamu     Emir Of Yashikira     Roseline Oni Aremu     Olanrewju Okanlawon Musa     Ilorin General Hospital     Razaq Atunwa     Ahmed Idris Mohammed     TVC Female National Debate     Kayode Bankole     Ubandoma     Bello Bature     KWATMA     Olayinka Jelili Yusuf     GAMA     Rashidi Yekini     Anilelerin     Ajibike Katibi     PAACO-PCL Consortium     Government House     Aisha Abodunrin Ibrahim     Iliasu     Usman Yunusa     Emmanuel Bello     Ajasse-Ipo     Adamu Jemilat-Baki     Doyin Group     Ayobami Akanbi     Jare Olatundun     Christopher Tunji Ayeni     Abdulkadri Ahmad Alaiye     Kayode Ishola     Abdulrahman Abdulrasak     Dairo Kunle Paul     Kwara State Polytechnic     Olokoba     ER-KANG     Kale Bayero     Samuel Elizabeth Keatswa     Adeniyi Ojo     Ogbondoroko     Ahmed Bayero     Dagbalodo     Siddiq Adebayo Idowu Salawu     Lateef Ademola Olatunji     Ashiru     Iyaloja-General     Olateju Lukman     Toyin Saraki     Yeketi     Modibbo Kawu     Oyelere Oyinloye     Chemiroy Nigeria Limited     Press Release    

Cloud Tag: What's trending

Click on a word/phrase to read more about it.

Labaeka     Barakat Community Secondary School     Sodiya     Opaleke Bukola Iyabo     Abdulrahman Abdulrasak     Jimba Babatunde     Vasolar Consultoria     Yusuf Amuda Aluko     Sarafadeen Kayode Akorede     Bolaji Nagode     Mohammed Ghali Alaaya     Read With Me     Adeleke Ogungbe     Hakeem Lawal     Ibrahim Taiwo     Bamidele Adegoke Oladimeji     KWASSIP     AbdulFatai Adeniyi Dan-Kazeem     Cassava Growers\' Association     Oniyangi Kunle Sulaiman     Arinola Lawal     Obayomi Azeez     Yinka Aluko     Ibrahim Akaje     Kwara State Internal Revenue Service     Kayode Oyin Zubair     KWACOBPA     Erin-ile     Khairat Gwadabe     Folashade Omoniyi     National Pilot     Mohammed Khadijat Kubura     Alikinla     Danhawa     Jawondo     Clement Yomi Adeboye     Suleiman Alege Kuranga     Ganmo     Federal Road Maintenance Agency     Joseph Alex Offorjama     VADA     Sheikh Ridhwanullah     Taofeek Sanusi     Amule Elementary School     Olateju Lukman     Ibrahim Mashood     Mary Arinde     Sherif Shagaya     Olabimpe Olani     Ubandoma Of Ilorin     Government High School (GHS), Adeta     Aisha Abodunrin Ibrahim     Yomi Adeboye     Olatunde Jare     Justina Oha     Onilu     Modibbo Kawu     Ilorin East/South Federal Constituency     Lawal Olohungbebe     Kwara North     Yusuf Olaolu Ali     Isau     Salihu Alhaji Musa     Afonja     Ndama Al-hassan     Umar Bayo Abdulwahab     Iyabo Adewuyi     Mumeen Lah     Kale Ayo     Lawal Arinola Kudirat     Aliyu Muhammad Saifudeen     Earlyon Technologies     Kazeem Adekanye     Ezekiel Yissa Benjamin     Magaji Nda     Yusuf Abdulraheem     Shuaib Jawondo