CCT: Court of Appeal reserves judgment on Saraki's appeal

Date: 2016-10-06

The Court of Appeal in Abuja on Thursday reserved judgment in an appeal filed by the Senate President, Bukola Saraki, challenging the jurisdiction of the Code of Conduct Tribunal (CCT) to trial him.

Justice Abdu Aboki-led other four justices of the appellate court reserve the date after parties had adopted their written addresses.

Aboki said that the date of the judgment would be communicated to the parties.

The notice of appeal was filed on March 24 after Saraki’s motion challenging the jurisdiction of the tribunal was dismissed.

Adopting his address, Mr Kanu Agabi (SAN), Counsel to Saraki, urged the appellate court to upturn the decision of the tribunal which had arrogated to itself jurisdiction to try the applicant.

“That is to say that the tribunal has no jurisdiction to entertain the charge brought against my client,’’ he said.

Agabi argued that under Section 3(d) of the Code of Conduct Bureau and Tribunal Act, anyone alleged to have breached the provision must be given an opportunity for a written admission.

He submitted that the non-compliance of the provision presupposed that the tribunal declared that legislation unconstitutional.

“That is why we are here. Leaving an inferior court like the CCT to declare an important legislation unconstitutional will be fatal,’’ he said.

Agabi further said that the applicant should not have been taken to the tribunal, adding that Saraki was not given his full right of admittance to the error spotted in his assert declaration forms.

“If the Code of Conduct Bureau had followed the provision of the law we would not have been here. Saraki was not given the right of fair hearing and we are surprised why this happened.

“In the light of this, there is no statement from the applicant which should have been accompanied with the prosecution’s proof of evidence as stipulated in the Administration of Justice Act.

“The other aspect is for the appellate court to decide whether it is right not to treat all identical cases equally,’’ Agabi said.

He also said: “we are saying this because the tribunal had some time ago ruled itself out of a similar case filed against Sen. Bola Tinubu.’’

Agabi submitted that it was clear that the action against the applicant was not in the interest of justice.

According to him, it amounts to judicial absurdity to bring the applicant to court on alleged offence committed 13 years ago.

“The Code of Conduct Bureau exists as a reconciliatory unit meant to correct errors spotted in asserts declaration forms and not created to send people to prison.

“I urge the court to impress it on the two institutions to do the needful by availing the applicant the opportunity for a written admission.

“I also pray the court to hold that the tribunal does not have the jurisdiction to try the applicant in the circumstance,’’ Agabi said.

Agabi further averred that it was a breach of statutory provision that established the Code Conduct Bureau for either the EFCC or ICPC to assist it prosecuted alleged offences bordering around assets declaration.

“In this case, the EFCC was brought in to investigate and prosecute the applicant,’’ he said.

On his part, Chief Rotimi Jacobs (SAN), the Prosecuting Counsel, prayed the court to dismiss the appeal, adding that it lacked merit.

On Agabi’s submission that the applicant was not given the right of written admission, Jacob said that provision was an old law.

Jacob said Section 3(d) of the Code of Conduct Bureau and Tribunal Act was contained in the 1979 Constitution but expunged from the amended 1999 Constitution.

“I want to also make it clear before My Lords that the written statement of admission is different from the statement of defence that must accompany the proof of evidence.

“The applicant was given sufficient right to file objections to all the allegations brought against him, therefore, it will be unfair for his counsel to claim that he was not given fair hearing,’’ Jacob said.

Jacob also said the immunity status accorded the applicant by the constitution while being governor of Kwara for eight years delayed his prosecution, adding that it was not a case of selective justice.

In a cross appeal filed by the prosecution team, the applicant was accused of abusing court process, as according to Jacob, most of the reliefs sought has been heard and decided by the Supreme Court.

Source

 


Cloud Tag: What's trending

Click on a word/phrase to read more about it.

Abdulquowiyu Olododo     Abdulsalam Firdaous Amosa     AbdulRauf Keji     Oladimeji Thompson     Joseph Daudu     Basic Education Certificate Examination     Ganiyu Taofiq     MAI Akande     QuickWin     Aremu Odolaye     Moses Afolayan     Saliu Ajibola Ajia     CUTI     PAACO-PCL Consortium     Odo-Owa     Umar Yakubu Jaja     Aisha Buhari     Arca Santa     Alapado     Suraj Tunji Oyewale     Ali Ahmad     College Of Health     KWSIEC     Lateef Alagbonsi     Abdulganiyu Salahudeen     Abubakar Baba Sulaiman     Benin Republic     Kaiama     Saad Omo\'ya     Eleja     James Kolo     Ilorin West     Ejidongari     Toyin Saraki     Quareeb Islamic Association     Ibrahim Abdulqadir Abikan     Ajikobi     Alimi Abdulrazaq     Maryam Ado Bayero     A.O. Belgore     Saidu Kawu     Bank Of Industry     Sulaiman Gado     CT Ayeni     Odolaye Aremu     Kwara State Fish Farmers Association     Read With Me     Salaudeen Oyewale     Binta Abubakar Mora     Muhammad Yahya     NSCIA     Ndakene     Lai Gobir     Col. Adedipe     Ishaq Abdulkarim     Olatunde Michaels     Eruku     Balogun Ajikobi     Abubakar Ndakene     Frootify     Ibraheem Adeola Katibi     Olupako Of Share     Emir Of Lafiagi     Amos Justus Sayo     Nupe     NIPOGA     Logun     Kwara 2019     Shero     Yusuf Abubakar     Kwara Muslim Pilgrims Welfare Board     Zaratu Umar     Moses Adekanye     Local Government     Yahaya A Paniyaro     Garba Ado Sanni     Abubakar Abdullahi Bata    

Cloud Tag: What's trending

Click on a word/phrase to read more about it.

Alimi Abdulrazaq     Ibrahim Abdullahi     Ilorin Talaka Parapo     Abdulrauf Aliyu     Abdulmajeed Abdullahi     20 Billion Bond     Michael Ologundea     Dogara     Offa Descendants Union     Laolu Saraki     Hamidu Olowo     Fatai Garuba Labaka     Bukola Saraki     Mahfouz Adedimeji     Women Radio     Charles Ibitoye     Ali Ahmad     Ganmo Power Sub-Station     Kwara South     Neuropsychiatric Hospital     Iyabo Dupe Adekeye     Abiodun Abdulkareem     Ayodele Kuburat Olaosebikan     Inside Kwara     Convocation Ceremonies     Pakata     Opolo Global Innovation Limited     Kayode Bankole     Oba David Oyerinola Adedunmoye     Chikanda     Kayode Issa     Eghe Igbinehi     Sardauna Of Ilorin     Oasis Muslim Care Foundation     Alloy Chukwuemeka     Hamid Bobboyi     Ibrahim Issa Jetti     Sa\'adu Salau     Gbemi Saraki     Oloye     Valsolar     Suleiman Ajadi     Apaola     Dapo Teni Nig Enterprise     Economic And Financial Crimes Commission     Kazeem Adekanye     Asa LGEA School     Haliru Dantoro     Okeose Christian Cementary     Owode Market     Muslimah Entrepreneurship Forum     John Olajide Adedipe     Computer Based Test     Olokoba Abdullahi Ayinla     Babaita     Bola Olukoju     KWSUED     Elerin Of Adanla     Muhammad Yahya     Mazars Consulting     Ramadan     Ilorin Emirate Stakeholders Forum     Oba Sulaiman Asude     Abubakar B.M     Victor Gbenga Yusuf     Aliyu Muhammad Saifudeen     Okasanmi Ajayi     Oloriegbe     Clara Nwachukwu     Biliaminu Aliu     Abdulrasheed Akogun     Oke-Odo     Ohoro Of Shao     Muhammadu Buhari     Oro Grammar School     Oja-Oba     Madawaki